Opinion: We the People: The Death Penalty

In this week's "We the People," Megan Leckie and Brennon Goss spar over the death penalty.

By Guest (Editor) on Tuesday February 21, 2012

Size: A A A

By Brennon Goss and Megan Leckie | Staff Writers | February 21, 2012

In this week’s “We the People,” Megan Leckie and Brennon Goss spar over the death penalty.

Brennon: How would you feel if someone shot a loved one in cold blood without any trace of remorse? The SOB freely admitted it in court, even bragged about it. In response for his confession, the jury sentences him to 20 years with possibility of parole.

While this may be slightly exaggerated, how livid would the family of the victim be that this murderer could be set loose?! Wouldn’t you want that bastard to pay with his life for what he stole from you?!

While extreme, the death penalty is the supreme punishment of the land, reserved for people who commit murder, treason or espionage. Crimes of the highest degree. Wouldn’t the very threat of this punishment be a deterrent to those considering to commit these heinous crimes?  Why should convicted killers receive leniency? They deprived an innocent person of their life, why do they deserve to live theirs in the relative comfort and safety of the modern prison system.

Megan: The best payment for someone who has done something as awful as taking another innocent human life is, in my eyes, a lifetime of rotting in a tiny jail cell. In all honesty, which fate is worse? Dying, or spending the rest of your livable years confined behind bars from freedom and the pursuit of happiness with no hope of escaping?

I don’t think dying is penance enough for such a crime. In fact, I get a sort of dark satisfaction at the thought of someone sitting idol for years and years with nothing to look forward to but the threat of violence and oppression looming over their guilty heads.

Not to mention that jail is incredibly boring. The amount of entertainment available is inversely proportional to the amount of down time prisoners have. With all that down time, eventually the worst of human emotions start to kick in: guilt and remorse. What a lot of people fail to realize about convicted murderers is that, they are going to feel sorry. Whether this is genuine guilt over the loss of life, or the remorse of getting caught and losing everything.

Brennon: Were we living in the 18th century I may have agreed with you, but nowadays the prison system has come under fire for being “cruel or unusual” so many times which resulted in more and better commodities and comfort for inmates such as televisions, gyms, visiting hours, dental and medical care, three hot meals a day, etc.

I’m not saying that prisons should be a torture chamber, but there should be some truth behind the saying “serving hard time.” And it’s funny that you say they will rot away for a lifetime, yet are some are paroled in less than 10 years, then go back to butchering innocent people.

The death penalty’s greatest strength lies not with the punishment in itself, but in its very existence. The fear of execution can be an amazing deterrent to crime.

Take Dwain Little for example. In 1966 he raped and stabbed a 16-year-old girl and was sentenced to life in prison. He was paroled in 1974 after serving only 8 years of a life sentence.

He then proceeded to gun down a family of four in 1980. And again he was given a life sentence. And thankfully they actually carried through this time, but this man obviously did not feel the guilt or remorse you say happens “one way or another.”

I just feel that if people think that they could be home free from stealing another persons life in eight short years then they would be more willing to commit those acts because, hey its only eight years, they behead people for this in Saudi Arabia. But if there is a genuine threat of execution for committing the heinous act of butchering a human being, often times for no real reason, then there might be fewer takers.

The death penalty’s greatest strength lies not with the punishment in itself, but in its very existence. The fear of execution can be an amazing deterrent to crime.

I’m almost positive your next point will discuss how innocent people are often executed, and I’d like to address that. Executing an innocent man is a travesty and by no means a trivial affair to be taken lightly, however this whole situation is more of a problem with the jury, not the punishment itself.

The jury decides the punishment, the execution just carries it out. And yes juries are human beings and are therefore fallible but this does not mean that justice should be taken lightly instead. Perhaps in the spirit of compromise, only those who confessed guilty to first degree murder would be eligible for execution.

Megan: Obviously Dwain Little being released after 8 years is a fluke in the parole system, not any issue with the death penalty. Not to mention that he is an obvious psychopath, who does not have the emotional capacity to feel remorse. Those sorts of criminals are different stories entirely, and should be in an asylum rather than a jail cell.

Many criminals carrying out a life sentence do come to regret their actions, often much later in their life when they have had a sufficient fill of the justice system or have clear hindsight after being off whatever cocktail of drugs they were on.

Had Mr. Little been (properly) locked away for the rest of his years, he would not have had the opportunity to escape and kill again. The solution to dangerous criminals getting out on parole and going back to a life of crime is not to kill them, but to — stay with me here — not let them out of jail.

I do understand that keeping someone in prison for the majority of their lives is not cheap. Prisoner care costs money, often more than the prison itself takes in.

But again, this is an issue that needs to be addressed regarding the prison system itself (and while its true that there have been vast improvements, there still the issue of having all of your rights and property taken. And the threat of gang violence at every turn).

The whole business of killing people as punishment seems a little hypocritical, doesn’t it? And if it’s not hypocritical, it is certainly a little senseless. Killing the murderer does not bring the victim back, so it hardly seems fair to send them off without the years of torment they earned themselves. If a murderer is being prosecuted for killing on the grounds that no one has the right to end another life, how on earth do we justify killing them as punishment?

If one person doesn’t have the right to kill another, then neither does the government, a jury, or any sort of establishment. Anything that is run by humans is prone to human error.

If the punishment itself cannot be applied to the established legal system, what place does it have there at all? The law of the land is trial by jury, so punishment must be able to be dealt by a jury and retracted if evidence comes up to prove the verdict wrong. Once someone is killed, it’s done. There’s no going back from that.

There is no giving back a life taken, one way or another.  If the law is “No Killing,” then it must apply to everyone without exception.

Editor - sbkerfuffle@gmail.com

Nobody's commented yet on Opinion: We the People: The Death Penalty:

Leave a Comment

Please complete all available fields. Your email address will not be published, but if you have a Gravatar account associated with the address, your avatar will be displayed next to your comment.


− four = zero

All comments are subject to our comment policy.

Click here to show our latest articles.
Click here to hide the articles.
DP Science Club Takes Second Place at 2015 JPL Science Bowl Regional Competition

DP Science Club Takes Second Place at 2015 JPL Science Bowl Regional Competition

After an intense comeback in the playoffs and beating some of the best high school teams in the region, members of the DP Science Club took home second place at the 2015 Regional High School Science Bowl competition, losing to Arcadia High School’s team.

DP Students Nominated for Presidential Scholars Program

DP Students Nominated for Presidential Scholars Program

Seniors Ameet Braganza, Adam Dai and Brian Su candidates for Washington, D.C. honor

Sports Round-up: Week of 03/08 to 03/14

Sports Round-up: Week of 03/08 to 03/14

Cox competes in CIF State Wrestling Championships | Baseball loses two of three games | Boys volleyball beats Oxnard | Softball wins three of four games | Lacrosse loses both its games to San Marcos | Varsity girls and JV boys win in track/field dual meet against Buena, many athletes place in weekend meets | Boys tennis wins two of three games | Swim/Dive wins in tri-meet | Boys golf loses two of three games

Photo Gallery: Grease Pole 2015, DP Tradition

Photo Gallery: Grease Pole 2015, DP Tradition

On Friday the annual grease pole took place in Dos Pueblos’ Greek theater. The grease pole is a competition in which 3-student teams (all seniors) attempt to climb a pole coated with slick grease. This has been a tradition for many years at DP and each year a wider variety of participants try their hand […]

Intramural Dodgeball Comes to DP

Intramural Dodgeball Comes to DP

DP students will compete in a co-ed intramural dodgeball tournament the Thursdays at lunch.

New Wellness Policy Restricts Student Organizations From Distributing Unhealthy Food

New Wellness Policy Restricts Student Organizations From Distributing Unhealthy Food

Food sold by Virtual Enterprise's Cart Mart and by clubs on International Day now regulated

46th Dos Pueblos Jazz Festival: A rocking performance

46th Dos Pueblos Jazz Festival: A rocking performance

Dos Pueblos’ Advanced Jazz band performed along with Grammy-award-winning saxophonist Bob Mintzer, Grammy-nominated Latin Jazz star Bobby Rodriguez and Gary Pratt with his Cal State Northridge Band in an evening concert on Mar. 7 as a part of DP’s 46th annual Jazz Festival. For almost 50 years, DP has hosted an annual Jazz Festival: a […]

Dougal R. House: the “Back Half’s” Volunteer Curator

Dougal R. House: the “Back Half’s” Volunteer Curator

House has been caring for Dos Pueblos’ forested area and creek for over 30 years

Sports Round-up: Week of 03/01 to 03/07

Sports Round-up: Week of 03/01 to 03/07

Baseball loses against two teams | Boys Volleyball loses to Newbury Park | Softball loses to Camarillo | Lacrosse loses to Santa Barbara | Track athletes place in Don Green Invite | Boys Tennis loses to Campbell Hall | Boys Golf beats Saint Bonaventura

Social Equality Club Works To Make All Students Feel Accepted

Social Equality Club Works To Make All Students Feel Accepted

Club recently received a $1,890 grant from Youth Making Change, a grant-making organisation run by teens

Boys Lacrosse Returns for Its Sophomore Season

Boys Lacrosse Returns for Its Sophomore Season

On Wednesday the team fell to San Marcos at home in the first Varsity game of the season, 9-3

Boys’ Soccer Wins League Title for First Time Since 1983

Boys’ Soccer Wins League Title for First Time Since 1983

Team finished league undefeated, with a record of 6-0-2 in Channel League games

Charger Spotlight: Juliet James

Charger Spotlight: Juliet James

Dos Pueblos freshman Juliet James is pushing skating to the next level.

Sports Round-up: Week of 02/22 to 02/28

Sports Round-up: Week of 02/22 to 02/28

Girls Soccer Loses in CIF | Cameron Cox Advances in State | Boys Tennis Wins First Game of Season | Baseball Loses First Game of Season | Spring Sports Start This Week

Photo Gallery: Leadership Airbands 2015

Photo Gallery: Leadership Airbands 2015

Students flocked to the Greek on Friday at lunch to watch the Leadership Airbands - leadership students performing stunts in their various consecutive dance skits.

Opinion: Is Skating a Crime?

Opinion: Is Skating a Crime?

Most people describe skating culture as being immature, destructive, and uncivilized. But where else are you going to find a culture that doesn't judge you by your skin color, age, economic status, or by the clothes you wear?

Sports Round-up: Week of 02/15 to 02/21

Sports Round-up: Week of 02/15 to 02/21

Girls soccer wins CIF game and moves on in CIF | Three wrestlers move on individually to CIF Masters Meet | Other winter sports end their seasons in CIF | Spring sports to start this week

Sports Round-up: Week of 02/08 to 02/14

Sports Round-up: Week of 02/08 to 02/14

Boys Basketball wins last game, girls move on to CIF | Girls and Boys soccer advance to CIF | Wrestling athletes move on to CIF Individuals | Girls Water Polo moves on to CIF

Disney’s “McFarland, USA” brings authentic story to SBIFF

Disney’s “McFarland, USA” brings authentic story to SBIFF

"McFarland, USA" is a feel-good sports underdog movie - and an inspiring true story

Cheating: Can It Really Be Stopped?

Cheating: Can It Really Be Stopped?

Over 65 percent of surveyed students admit to violations of academic integrity policy

SBIFF: Cousteau Family Honored with Attenborough Award

SBIFF: Cousteau Family Honored with Attenborough Award

Cousteaus are known worldwide for educating the public on the importance of protecting the ocean: after father Jacques came son Jean-Michel and grandchildren Fabien and Celine

Advanced classes offer students higher-level learning

Advanced classes offer students higher-level learning

Various IB, AP, Honors and Engineering classes provide students with advanced options

Sports Round-up: Week of 02/01 to 02/07

Sports Round-up: Week of 02/01 to 02/07

Soccer: Boys win, girls eye Channel League title for first time in 30 years | Girls Water Polo plays against six teams, wins vs. half | Wrestling CIF championship narrowly lost | Basketball loses vs SB, Buena

Kevin Sheffield: The Heavy-Metal Math Teacher

Kevin Sheffield: The Heavy-Metal Math Teacher

Popular DP teacher travels the world, and enjoys motorcycles and a good laugh

Opinion: Compromise Needed in Net Neutrality

Opinion: Compromise Needed in Net Neutrality

New regulations can't be an extreme on either side, or they will not pass.

Chargers’ Emotions Turbulent After Super Bowl XLIX

Chargers’ Emotions Turbulent After Super Bowl XLIX

“Carroll should be fired. They made a highschool mistake and it was a quick slam.” - DP Junior

Charger Inn Students Get “Chopped”

Charger Inn Students Get “Chopped”

From left, Caesar Medina, Jessica Flores and Megan Hollingsworth, DP seniors, in the finals week competition (Photos by Alex Lam) Dos Pueblos’ Charger Inn students participated in a “Chopped”-style competition for their first semester final, cooking gourmet meals using unknown ingredients that were given out by the instructor. Ingredients ranged from dried chicken to almonds, and […]

Sports Round-up: Week of 01/18 to 01/24

Sports Round-up: Week of 01/18 to 01/24

Wrestlers take individual titles, team championship at SM | Boys Soccer wins vs. Buena, SM | Girls Soccer ties Buena, wins vs. SM| Girls Water Polo wins vs. Ventura | Girls Basketball wins vs. SM, loses to Buena | Boys Basketball loses to Buena, SM

Bell Schedule, Though Popular, Doesn’t Lower D/F Rate

Bell Schedule, Though Popular, Doesn’t Lower D/F Rate

Survey results reflect support for new schedule, though issues in time usage and transportation remain

Press Access Restored to Student Journalists Covering SBIFF

Press Access Restored to Student Journalists Covering SBIFF

After being told for the second year in a row by Santa Barbara International Film Festival staff that no press access would be available to student press, local student media groups reached a compromise on Jan. 12 that will allow students considerable but limited access to the festival. When local schools received emails informing them […]

Students Honored, Birthday Celebrated at Student Senate Meeting

Students Honored, Birthday Celebrated at Student Senate Meeting

DP Trailblazers and Student of the Month honored Jan. 20

Music Review: “Evermotion”

Music Review: “Evermotion”

Best known for their single "Satellite," Guster returns with a new and unique album

Photo Gallery: Visual Arts Students Showcase Pop Art

Photo Gallery: Visual Arts Students Showcase Pop Art

Color and design students display their Pop Art

Music Review: “The Dream Walker”

Music Review: “The Dream Walker”

Fast paced, tantalizing modern beats flow through Angels & Airwaves’ new album "The Dream Walker."

Turnovers Plague Chargers in Loss to Dons

Turnovers Plague Chargers in Loss to Dons

SB defeated DP 69-47 in an eventful home game on Friday

DP Theater Company Awarded Numerous Honors

DP Theater Company Awarded Numerous Honors

On Jan. 15, the Dos Pueblos Theatre Company took seven honors - including Theatre Company of the Year - in the Santa Barbara section of BroadwayWorld.com awards.

DP Beats Buena 21-4 in Girls Water Polo

DP Beats Buena 21-4 in Girls Water Polo

Four girls with three or more goals apiece assured DP's varsity victory in the game Tuesday at home vs. Buena High

Charger Spotlight: Emily Robinson, Creator of Worlds

Charger Spotlight: Emily Robinson, Creator of Worlds

Just over three years in, and four books penned. Emily Robinson works as a Dos Pueblos High School senior during the day and moonlights as an author, a creator of worlds with dragons, time travel and alternate dimensions. Robinson has been writing books since a young age, and has continued to do so through high […]

Chargers Mourn Oregon’s Loss in National Championships

Chargers Mourn Oregon’s Loss in National Championships

Most students favored the Oregon Ducks, with the Buckeyes the definite underdogs before Ezekiel Elliott carried his team to victory

Photo of the Day: Girls Soccer JV vs. SB at Home

Photo of the Day: Girls Soccer JV vs. SB at Home

DP lining up for a kick during the game this Tuesday after school. The JV girls tied 1-1, and varsity won 3-2. (Photo | Michael Aling)

New Clubs on Campus

New Clubs on Campus

Looking to make good on New Year's resolutions? It's not too late to join some of this academic year's new clubs - one way to get involved with the Dos Pueblos community.

DP Students Partake in Hour of Code

DP Students Partake in Hour of Code

Have you ever wanted to learn how to program computers? Many Dos Pueblos students recently had the opportunity to do just that by participating the the Hour of Code event that took place Dec. 9. Students were taught the basic concepts of computer programming through a series of web-based games featuring popular characters from Angry […]

Photo of the Day: Austrialians Arrive at DP

Photo of the Day: Austrialians Arrive at DP

This year's batch of Australian foreign exchange students arrived in an airbus today to meet their host families.

Photo Gallery: Behind DP’s Murals

Photo Gallery: Behind DP’s Murals

The volunteer National Art Honors Society and the art club have been painting murals around campus for years, and are responsible for all of the murals on campus.

Mockingjay Part One: A quiet beginning to the finale of the Hunger Games

Mockingjay Part One: A quiet beginning to the finale of the Hunger Games

Though the filmmakers have been heavily criticized for breaking the movie into two parts, drawing it out and making it less exciting, Lauren Caspersen has to disagree.

Photo Gallery: Shred Everything!

Photo Gallery: Shred Everything!

Skating and BMXing push local teens to their limits - learn the lingo, see the tricks

Dos Pueblos hosts Noche al Colegio

Dos Pueblos hosts Noche al Colegio

DP's first college night in Spanish

DPEA Students Program MappApp in 54-hour Google Competition

DPEA Students Program MappApp in 54-hour Google Competition

Engineering students Spencer Mullanix, Landon Brand, Zachary Zerman and DP alum Reed Mullanix won the Best Minimum Viable Product award for their efforts.

Woodshop Classes Embark on House-building Project “Tiny”

Woodshop Classes Embark on House-building Project “Tiny”

The documentary-inspired house will be built on a trailer and sold, with proceeds to benefit SBUSD woodshop programs

Video: Mason, DP Teacher, Wins Distinguished Mentor Award

Video: Mason, DP Teacher, Wins Distinguished Mentor Award

The award, one of three, was provided by the Santa Barbara County Education office for Mason's role in mentoring current and former students (some now teachers.)

New Locker Rooms Bring Changes in Physical Education Classes

New Locker Rooms Bring Changes in Physical Education Classes

New locker and shower facilities are ready for use, allowing PE classes to intensify.

Colleges Compete for Senior Soccer Player Julio Rubio

Colleges Compete for Senior Soccer Player Julio Rubio

Five top-notch schools competed for Dos Pueblos senior Julio Rubio after he helped Santa Barbara Soccer Club win 18 games in multiple tournaments to be crowned national champions last summer.

Charger Athletes Face Health Risks

Charger Athletes Face Health Risks

Student athletes face dangerous consequences due to concussions

Go to the archives.